Celtic Heroes

Even so, the reason given was naming and shaming users.

OK someone at OTM explain to me this:

The game says who is demoting and kicking players as it happens.
Therefor everyone in clan chat for sure seen who was doing this.
So an actual player that cares about his clan comes onto forums to let people know of this Toons actions.
The Toon that did it knows what he was doing is wrong.
By blocking his name only shows that OTM supports scamming/bad players.
Because in this instance as well as every other one like this 1 person is doing something bad, the other is trying to inform others about it.
No bashing was done here, what was being done is simply letting people know the truth of what happened.
If that Toon didnt want the baggage that came along with booting everyone from clan, then he shouldn't of done it.
Naming and shaming is a crime when the player that is being named and shamed over things that aren't true.
If a person steals an item from a player and that player comes on forums and says this player scammed me, THIS IS WHERE OTM NEEDS TO CHECK TRADE/CHAT LOGS AND SEE IF THE PERSON WAS SCAMMED.
If he was OTM needs to leave the persons name alone as the scammed earned the baggage that comes along with scamming.
Why police forums if you can't police your own game?

Its just me but I would think its easyer to get someone who dont know a thing about the game code to keep people in line on forum rules then it would be to have people to read game codes in order to see if some one got scammed.

I have sent in images of the scammer bragging about how he got away with it and nothing was done.
But if you say something helful in the forums there is someone to stop / edit you.

The time and effort to support a good gaming effort is dumpped more so in forum etiquette than in fair gaming.

If a scammer or just a bad players name shouldn't be removed since its in WORLD FORUMS an is between the people on that server and not in public forums

You should use the in-game support tool to report the user.

He isn't reporting anyone he simply said that someone once they gained a guard spot in clan kicked all members.
This isn't about a scam and if is true in Clan chat would say who did it so this is not secret information.
Why his name was removed is yet another sign of lack of experience.

People could see this as disruptive so may be a reason to report the user to be looked at. As in any scamming case, people can still name and shame using the in-game chat but just not on the forums. The name was removed because the player was being shamed as kicking other users out of a clan.

You should use the in-game support tool to report the user.

He isn't reporting anyone he simply said that someone once they gained a guard spot in clan kicked all members.
This isn't about a scam and if is true in Clan chat would say who did it so this is not secret information.
Why his name was removed is yet another sign of lack of experience.

People could see this as disruptive so may be a reason to report the user to be looked at. As in any scamming case, people can still name and shame using the in-game chat but just not on the forums. The name was removed because the player was being shamed as kicking other users out of a clan.

Soooo posting an action of another is also not allowed in the forums..

You should use the in-game support tool to report the user.

He isn't reporting anyone he simply said that someone once they gained a guard spot in clan kicked all members.
This isn't about a scam and if is true in Clan chat would say who did it so this is not secret information.
Why his name was removed is yet another sign of lack of experience.

People could see this as disruptive so may be a reason to report the user to be looked at. As in any scamming case, people can still name and shame using the in-game chat but just not on the forums. The name was removed because the player was being shamed as kicking other users out of a clan.

The whole point is it is the truth. I can understand censorship in speculation cases and such but the forums have just gotten ridiculous. I understand your just enforcing rules you may not even agree with yourself, but these new rules are a bunch of crap.

Edit: http://www.celtic-heroes.com/forum/view ... 98#p186698

Woah! Where did that link come from? No idea.