Celtic Heroes

I think dicing works if there are no tiers, and bosses drop godly/void every time. Eventually everyone will get their turn it's just a matter of time.
However in CH, it takes years to even get another Godly item of the same type, so the rarest/most powerful items should be distributed smartly.

Actually, BoE is what kills dicing. If I earn a godly assassinate bracer Id pass on my imperial to someone else that needs it. If they were BoE Dkp would be the way to go. usually the person that wins passes on their less wanted tier to the next most deserving player that could use it which is the only way it has an advantage. Other than that, no one would spend dkp on a low tier drop, they'd wait for the highest. It keeps items that could potentially be used out of circulation but it keeps them on toons that may not quite deserve it. They've both got ups and downs. I like dkp honestly

Nah, if all drops were Godly/Void, then everyone will eventually get one and it doesn't matter if they're BoE. Just like all DL armor/weapons are the same, it doesn't matter if people quit, we would get more of them. Hence why dicing usually works on DL quest items. But just imagine if DL weapons were also tiered, like Dark Dragonlord Dagger, Shadow Dragonlord Dagger and Void Dragonlord dagger, dicing would just screw all the Snorri campers over and over.