I do partly agree with the OP. A lot of the winners didn't have amazing drawings, but something that all competitions test lately are creativity. Some of us are more creative than others, and all the competitions seem to draw upon this skill and nothing else. It would be nice to have more varied competitions in the future that include other groups of people.
I wouldn't say it's insulting to intelligence to have these competitions, but I see your point.
I wouldn't say it's insulting to intelligence to have these competitions I BEG TO DIFFER on this particular point.
One winner drawing is a clear RIP OFF of World of War Craft's cloud serpent/sky serpent/ chinese dragon mount. how in the world is that creative? thats my very point of insult to intelligence.
Some of us are more creative than others indeed. the cardboard maquette was a delightful surprise, and many others did admirable efforts on research.