Celtic Heroes

I think pies should be tradable as well. Just make it rarer for a high health one to drop.

Would you like some energy pies? We could add somethign to make those as well if you like.

+1


And +1 on making these pies (energy and health both) tradable.

I'm sorry but I'm a L97 ranger with less than 1K health in OW, and still don't use these pies, so they're sitting there collecting dust, as I wait for the latest change to revert.

Yes, I know this is probably an app update feature rather than a patch. A workaround could be to have three or four NPCs offering the same quest, but with different rewards. Gaston gives health pies, his colleague Frederic gives energy pies, etc.

See the wolf pelt quest from Una the Furrier in Highshore Village. She gives you the option of picking gloves, boots, or a scarf before you accept the quest. This may be something that can be implemented in the pie quest without a major update, and without adding more npcs.

Heeeey ! Amin is not actually a robot and can be sarcastic and use black humor with his customers !!! Thats indeed nice... But simply does not answer the question about getting our pies tradeable.

Nice way also to put away the topic main point by asking if we would like any other kind of pies. but I am going to be a nice positive customer and constructive too :

Please implement some special pies that can make us trade any pies in our backpack during 10 minutes. It would be fun to see in red some player shouting : "Selling pies, all can of pies, selling ending in 6 minutes !" lol just beeing once again sarcastic.

So.. Our pies... No trade or Tradeable once again in a foreseeing future ?

Yes, I know this is probably an app update feature rather than a patch. A workaround could be to have three or four NPCs offering the same quest, but with different rewards. Gaston gives health pies, his colleague Frederic gives energy pies, etc.

See the wolf pelt quest from Una the Furrier in Highshore Village. She gives you the option of picking gloves, boots, or a scarf before you accept the quest. This may be something that can be implemented in the pie quest without a major update, and without adding more npcs.

Oh nice idea!

+1

(and make them tradable!)

We can definitely make more quests with different types of pies, but the issue that was originally posted on the forum that pies would ruin boss fights is why we can't make them tradeable. They would basically break the boss encounters and instead of being fun the bosses would become trivial and therefore boring.

See the wolf pelt quest from Una the Furrier in Highshore Village. She gives you the option of picking gloves, boots, or a scarf before you accept the quest. This may be something that can be implemented in the pie quest without a major update, and without adding more npcs.

I'd forgotten about those quests. Thanks Bitey, and yes, this would be an excellent solution.

We can definitely make more quests with different types of pies, but the issue that was originally posted on the forum that pies would ruin boss fights is why we can't make them tradeable. They would basically break the boss encounters and instead of being fun the bosses would become trivial and therefore boring.

Would all due respect Admin, and I think one of the reasons why a lot of people are... peeved, is that you acted based on ONE person's comment. I think most people realize that this probably is not the case, but it sure does look that way.

Personally, tho I can see how the highest pie (1600?)can possibly ruin a boss fight, I fail to see how a 600 HP can do the same.

Edit:
Talking about this
http://www.onethumbmobile.com/celticher ... =6&t=17611
which was even pointed out a Singular Reason here
http://www.onethumbmobile.com/celticher ... 92#p115492

Would all due respect Admin, and I think one of the reasons why a lot of people are... peeved, is that you acted based on ONE person's comment. I think most people realize that this probably is not the case, but it sure does look that way.

In this case i don't think it was the quantity of the complaints, I think it was the quality of the complaint. You can get tons of people arguing in favor of a bad idea, but just because everyone wants it doesn't mean it should happen. And if only one person has a good idea, it doesn't mean that idea should be ignored because no one else thought of it.

I think, like the Una the Furrier quest, Gaston should offer Health pies OR Energy pies (you pick before the quest). If this is not the case, then I'd like a completely random pie. As someone stated, could be defence / attack / movement speed / or anything else you can think of

Also I think with all these options, that the pies should remain no-trade. Sometimes you will get a useful pie. Sometimes you will get a useless pie.. But Gaston isn't going anywhere