Frozen Armor is good for Fire Attacks cause of the resist and attacks like when druids root & that missing attack spell some cast on you which "frozen armor" makes them less harmful and able to dodge a lot to help save your health from decreasing such as when dragons blow fire at you and rogues try and use rend on you.
Okay and that other armor is good for having a greater chance for landing attacks and dodging a lot including spells and any class using super strong attacks such as Rogues Warriors Druids and mages main attacks that does the most damage costing a lot of things Heath to go down big time enough to save their life's.
Take notice the evasions on each armor read carefully and you'll see why both are greatly different and my choice would be "Frozen" for now "I myself not at you guys level to be worrying about dodging a lot", lol I'm too busy group leveling but that armor would be totally nice up against them Greystones… for my stats that is

“Repetition Is The Key Father of Learning”
Started in since 2011 - O.G.
Server: Morrigan
Rogue: GodOZilla Level 220
CLAN: HAVOC
YouTube Channel:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCfnHbhK9whlW35IhLcqtn_g