Celtic Heroes

I absolutely admire everyone's way of completely changing the topic.
We started at armor, then went to Druid and
Mages and now we end up at who is a better dps : Rogue or Mage.


As my part of this argument, or whatnot I would agree that rogues should be amazing in dps but that does not mean mages can't be good as well. Suppose their was a 1 v 1 fight for Crammok. A Mage vs a Rogue. If the rogue had say 800 damage it would be a close competition. (Keep in mind this is Crammok the guy in arena I think that's his name. If there is a battle for this the levels are both considerably lower than people killing Ragnor. Suppose they both are 125.) A Mage who is full dps and a H2H Mage would be quite good. The rogue would hit approximately 350-500 per auto. The Mage would have lures yet also hit 150-300 per auto hit. This significantly decreases the gap between the two. Now when a Mage starts casting , it can easily reduce the gap between the auto hits because ice shards hits 800+ and fire bolt and incinerate provide quick damage. This would be a very close battle and it would probably be the rogue winning but theage also has a chance.

The reason rogue would and should win though is because they only have one roll in the game. You might say rogue can tank but they aren't nearly as good. Mages have two good roles. They can be amazing supporters and good dps. A rogue on the other hand is EXCELLENT dps but decent tank ( for the best of them). Basically every class has two roles they can perform. When you weight them all down, they are quite closely matched.

Warrior: Extra-Ordinary Tank, Bad- Decent Dps
Mage: Amazing Support, Good Dps
Rogue: Excellent Dps, Decent Tank
Druid: Extra-ordinary support ( Heals, abundant aura, SoB, etc), Can be potentially good dps
Ranger: Amazing soloists: Good support.

Throughout the roles of these classes do even out.

Then Brookie I am not suggesting you are not a good rogue, but I have seen countless 120-130 rouges outdps 130-138 mages.

Even if they do outdps you occasionally, that does not necessarily mean they always will. There must be a slight factor change causing them to outdps you "sometimes"

Then Brookie I am not suggesting you are not a good rogue, but I have seen countless 120-130 rouges outdps 130-138 mages.

Even if they do outdps you occasionally, that does not necessarily mean they always will. There must be a slight factor change causing them to outdps you "sometimes"

no 120 rogue is outdpsing a 135 mage in dps spec

That's because the mage hasn't got the top gear or doesn't know how a mage works.

When a mage reaches aggy gear his maximum dps goes up by a friggin mile! Now im telling you i have best possible gear for my class. 4 godly firefang rings 2 radiant attack rings 2 aggy dagger braclets bloodlust full radiant 15 pirece neckless 100 dagger charm. I go against presmajic every time on aggy and when we fight he wins almost every time yet his gear isn't at the maximum possible point where mine is.

Please explain to me this?

If the mage is using hand to hand then they ent close to figuring out there top dps and they are doing there class all wrong. Pure spell mages own hand to hand at high lvl.