Celtic Heroes

Heya,

My two cents.....

Everyone agreed with the person chosen to be DM....which makes him/her legit
As Dm, he/she makes the final decision (since all agreed to him/her being the dm)
DM made the decison, no objections......He/she must have done the right thing

One reason we have groups or clannies, we look out for each other....if a clannie or even a group mate didn't call out that one of them lagged, maybe they didn't.....

So once the price/drop has been awarded, the decision becomes final and agreed upon by everyone.....

Since there were no objections, I might even say that people from the Same clan or group even congratulated the winner of the roll.

I let you guys read between the lines....

ciao

i vote give to elle

Hello all i was dm for this fight and take full responsibility for where ever this leads and apologize.

I gave drop to this person because i didn't know someone lagged, nor did anyone else, I felt it is only right to give her a chance to roll since she was camping and put in the work to roll, you cant blame her for lagging no one has control over something like that. there was plenty of witnesses who saw that she rolled higher then the person i gave drop too.

I say giving her the drop would be the right thing to do
Ty for time and again i apologize for this messy situation last time i dm lol

the dm says giving the drop to elle is the right thing to do
cmon randall it was a tank drop anyway :p

i vote give to elle

Hello all i was dm for this fight and take full responsibility for where ever this leads and apologize.

I gave drop to this person because i didn't know someone lagged, nor did anyone else, I felt it is only right to give her a chance to roll since she was camping and put in the work to roll, you cant blame her for lagging no one has control over something like that. there was plenty of witnesses who saw that she rolled higher then the person i gave drop too.

I say giving her the drop would be the right thing to do
Ty for time and again i apologize for this messy situation last time i dm lol

the dm says giving the drop to elle is the right thing to do
cmon randall it was a tank drop anyway :p

No backsies

While it would be extremely annoying if the user did lag and would have got the drop if it didn't happen, the only way they can rightfully own the drop is if there's evidence that they did actually roll the highest.

If no one has a screenshot or no one else can confirm that Randall didn't have the highest roll, then it would rightfully be yours. That's my opinion anyway.

Maybe it's worth a discussion with the user to come to some sort of agreement and figure out if the user is actually telling the truth and did lag.

Have screenshots...

Nevertheless, imo, once the drop has been given and the dicing session is ended distribution is final. The drop belongs to randall. But, considering the circumstances, it is worth talking about it and seeing if we can figure out what it fair.

The player who lagged came back and was asked to dice. She diced and rolled a 97. The player who recieved the drop from the dm diced a 92.

This story keeps evolving. First no one noticed. Then several noticed. Now she was asked to dice. Yet, it got so far that a topic was started on the forums. How was this not decided in-game immediately? Let's not forget that this individual was involved in the same EXACT situation before but she was the beneficiary of the drop. The only difference is that the drop didnt directly benefit her. It went to someone else. Fryphodie was denied a yellow crown based on this EXACT SAME PRINCIPLE. Funny how things change when you're on the other end of the result.

This story keeps evolving. First no one noticed. Then several noticed. Now she was asked to dice. Yet, it got so far that a topic was started on the forums. How was this not decided in-game immediately? Let's not forget that this individual was involved in the same EXACT situation before but she was the beneficiary of the drop. The only difference is that the drop didnt directly benefit her. It went to someone else. Fryphodie was denied a yellow crown based on this EXACT SAME PRINCIPLE. Funny how things change when you're on the other end of the result.

dear viru, fry may have been denied a yelllow crown since she's a druid, randall took a tank ring and left (Ironroot best tank set), all the people who diced stayed, i came back was asked to dice and diced. ang has screenshots which i didn't see yet but he told me that he has them like 2 days ago. randall asked the dm who the drop goes to, the dm said to elle. in fry's case, callator was the dm stayed silent after trading me the crown, he probably has blocked fry too to avoid answering her. i'm still a tank i got 14250hp still going up and tanking daily dl bosses and gearing Lugh from all clans not just alliance in private.
and this is what randal did:

- he left with the drop before any dicers left.
- he came back and refused to listen to the dm.
- he tried to run away from the responsibility of having the tank ring so he gave it to his clannie callator, who happened to be the first person who voted that he keeps ring. what a coincidence!
- he requested to make this thread on the forum to listen to people's opinion, which turned out mostly to re-roll.
- he did nothing about the results of his very own forum post. as in, he decided to take it to court and when the results came out, he betrayed his own self by keeping the ring with his clannie. he said he only loaned it to him, but until when? infinity time? doesn't make any sense.
- then he and callator started spreading anger among their clan, by actually pushing akbar to side with them. akbar suddenly shows up yesterday at boss 200 and comes up with a weird rule that alts cannot dice. well, most our alts are druids, they are the only reason why calltor stays alive when we fight the 200 boss. our mains do not keep the tank alive. akbar's excuse was that the drops were non class should be diced by one person. tell me viru, open this link and see, do these drops look like they're made for all classes equally??? http://www.celtic-heroes.com/forum/view ... =4&t=56700
and when i started explaining to akbar that the drops follow specific classes like +1000 nature magic to some set +200 armor to another, akbar sounded like he was hearing this for the first time. well he hasn't attended 200 boss fights on a daily basis and most probably he wasn't aware of the bonus sets that some of them follow specific classes and can benefit only that class. oh and this means to me that they actually used akbar, if i was akbar i would definitely feel used.
All for what? so that they try to scare me and made me back off and let go completely of having the right to own that tanking ring.
- randall who is by default the most genuinely nicest person in the game, suddenly decided to side with the dark side, and imo it's not the randall whom we know. it's definitely not the randall who used to whisper me when i dm dl drops "great job elle, i'm so proud of you". and tbh, i'm mostly concerned about what is happening with randall because it's not the same awesome person who we all love and know.
-

Your mage poisonous is wearing a stonebark necklace. Dont talk about classes and items.