Celtic Heroes

The Official Forum for Celtic Heroes, the 3D MMORPG for iOS and Android Devices

Re: Ranger Vs Rogue!

#51
Which is exactly why they are useless in groups other than bolas. They can do anything on their own, but when it comes to a clan, where there is many of each class which excel in the mix rangers have, rangers don't shine at all. It's basically a solo class and like I said before they shouldn't force a build on a class. AND since this game is so clan/cooperation based for gear and bossing, rangers are useless other than leveling. And whats the point of leveling if you won't be as useful as other classes on bosses?
This is completely inaccurate.

In my own experience in Seed, I think that Crom would be weeks behind where it is today without rangers cooperating with their clan: When the carrow/fingals/sewers first came out, and our clan was struggling to defeat the 150 wyrm boss. After quite a few failed attemps, I told the clan, "Can I just bolas him and have the tank run?"*. Of course the clan was reluctant as we only had 2 rangers at the time, including me. Eventually we got tired of failure and tried bolasing... and it worked. From there every boss was killed by bolasing it.
And that's how one skill on rangers have impacted boss fights.
*I don't claim to be the first person to come up with the idea of bolasing bosses, I was just the first person to suggest the idea on Crom

Furthermore: I don't know how many rangers use entangle, but let me spell out exactly how much it helps on a raid boss.
Take Mordis for example, she does about 1.5k damage a hit to our tanks. And she attacks fast. I haven't counted how many hits she does in 30 seconds, but its at least 1 hit a second, maybe more. That's 30*1500, 45000 damage. Entangle cuts that in half: 27500 damage that Mordis does not inflict on the tank.
Looking again at the paragraph above, I'm thinking the damage is probably a little unrealistic, I'm probably making a bad guess at the attack speed. But, my point remains, it still cuts the raid boss's damage in half, giving the druids some respite.

Further, Furthermore: Sharpen Weapons
Someone mentioned earlier that Sharpen Weapons pales in comparison to poison weapon. They are somewhat right, and also outrageously wrong.
Solo, sharpen weapons sucks. For me, it adds 102 damage to my attacks. It isn't really even worth casting in battle, as in the time it takes to cast, I could do a single auto hit for more damage than it would give me. However, if a group is attuned to how sharpen weapons works, you can increase the groups damage overall by about 800 a hit, and that is increased even more by a hate potion.
To show what I mean:
1 group, 1 ranger, sharpen weapons adds 100, each player attacks approximately every 2 seconds. (the attack speed is just a middle number, rouges would be hitting much closer to every 1 second, along with rangers, so the number below would really be much higher.)
Take sharpen weapon damage addition: 100, multiply by 8 for people in group: 800, and 800 every 2 seconds for 2 minutes = 48000 damage added by sharpen weapons per cast... Which leads me to continue comparing it to poison weaps. Poison has to recast per person to use it on, it might add 2 times, maybe up to 3 times the actual damage done by sharpen on a mob, but it has to be cast 8 times if it were to be used by everyone in a group, every time a rouge wants to cast poison weaps, it costs them an auto attack, or 2 or 3 on haste, on the mob they are attacking. With rangers, its cast once, then cast again in 2 minutes, where rouges would lose a great deal of their damage if they were poisoning everyone's weaps.

Further, Further, Furthermore: Someone said that rangers are just a debuff of all classes thrown in a blender.... again, highly inaccurate (and hurtful).
Rangers don't need to heal as much as druids, because they won't be healing the tank, they would be healing themselves or other dps.
Rangers don't need lures as they can simply buff the damage done by everyone through their person, not the add.
Rangers don't need armor since the mobs don't even get close. (Bolas/Camo)
But Rangers do deal tons of damage. It is highly dependent on who exactly you are comparing to who, and how well geared they are, but rangers on Crom can easily hold their own.

All classes have their disadvantages, and advantages, but you really can't say that any class would not be missed if it were taken out. Every class plays a role in Celtic Heroes, and they all must play their role, otherwise- everything would be much, much tougher on the other classes, probably even impossible.
Beautiful. +1


@AceBow most of the rangers ive lvled with are probably alts. But i know i have leveled with some who are not. Id say 75:25 ratio of alts:mains.

@Chelseam
Rangers can be solo or group. They can buff a group's damage, heal, bolas ect. They can also solo level by healing themselves, bolas, camo, dmg buffing. Rangers r easy to level solo (at least to level 100 because thats as far as i got.) I tried answering ur question to the best of my ability, hopefully i understood it right lol.

Re: Ranger Vs Rogue!

#52
One thing that is true for sure is that rangers are not as fun to play as rogues, when i speak as an endgame ranger i am heartbroken because all we do is rely on auto for damage. I have tried a dex ranger and trust me, it isnt required for end game.

I dont know how much i have to stress for this but rangers need skills, really bad. We are stuck with some skills that are a disgrace to support skills judging from recast time to effectiveness. If we were made as a support class why do we have mediocre support skills?
Wattzon of Sulis

Re: Ranger Vs Rogue!

#53
I dont know how much i have to stress for this but rangers need skills, really bad. We are stuck with some skills that are a disgrace to support skills judging from recast time to effectiveness. If we were made as a support class why do we have mediocre support skills?

I agree, rangers need massive skill buffs or additions.
Clan: WolfGang
Chaz - Level 185+ Ranger - Full DL
Inferno19 - Level 127+ Mage
Sneakystrike - Level 195+ Rogue - Full DL
EpIcHeaLzz - Level 137+ Druid
Tankerzz - Level 127+ Warrior (PvP Beast: Invincible Veteran)

World: Mabon

Re: Ranger Vs Rogue!

#54
What I also mean is, if anyone have reached level 170 and are right now trying to solo train they most likely are seen hanging around the 1-2 stars. Fast but not as much xp, ja? So basically while we are hanging around 2 starts you see these rogues hanging around in the rooms themselves using lixes and restos when you do the same exact thing soloing the 4 stars as fast as you kill the 2 stars (about) and getting more xp.


Then, say that you have light heal, dex build, cool but not good enough. Those 4 stars hit around 1.5k in their best skill attack. Light heal does about 1500 itself. Not to mention the autos those mobs impact on you. So you can only make your death not as soon as rogues. Cool.

Bolas and camo you say? Well, unlike you, I actually want to kill the mob and not just "evade" the mob and auto it to death. So basically you're spending all this time with camo and bolas recasting that you barely have enough time to even damage the mob. Thus making you just tank it and use restos. So then you end up doing exactly what the rogues do but just not THAT many restos do to light heal.


You would be SURPRISED what damage a ranger can do when it is not bolasing, recasting camo, and casting (interrupted time to time) light heal. I had a druid oog me once because he was bored and I was shocked by how much more efficient it was.


So, we DO, do well in group trainings but the problem is there are many stupid/blind people out there that do not care about efficiency and would rather just spend more money for the "quickest" kills and end up ONLY wanting a warrior/rogue team. Leaving the rangers out of the fun. No wonder I did not level my ranger that high, I had no leveling incentive. People like rogues would say leveling is booorinnggg but when I level I suddenly feel "happy" because I have not been able to for so damn long.
Ashley A - Mabon - Novalis - 222 - Mage
Azona - Mabon - Novalis - 209 - Druid
0x15 - Mabon - Novalis - 216 - Rogue

Allymia - Epona - 220 - Rogue
Fire Mage - Epona - 220 - Mage

Aethinry Donn - Belenus - 221 - Warrior
Dakara - Belenus - 200 - Mage

Re: Ranger Vs Rogue!

#55
What I also mean is, if anyone have reached level 170 and are right now trying to solo train they most likely are seen hanging around the 1-2 stars. Fast but not as much xp, ja? So basically while we are hanging around 2 starts you see these rogues hanging around in the rooms themselves using lixes and restos when you do the same exact thing soloing the 4 stars as fast as you kill the 2 stars (about) and getting more xp.


Then, say that you have light heal, dex build, cool but not good enough. Those 4 stars hit around 1.5k in their best skill attack. Light heal does about 1500 itself. Not to mention the autos those mobs impact on you. So you can only make your death not as soon as rogues. Cool.

Bolas and camo you say? Well, unlike you, I actually want to kill the mob and not just "evade" the mob and auto it to death. So basically you're spending all this time with camo and bolas recasting that you barely have enough time to even damage the mob. Thus making you just tank it and use restos. So then you end up doing exactly what the rogues do but just not THAT many restos do to light heal.


You would be SURPRISED what damage a ranger can do when it is not bolasing, recasting camo, and casting (interrupted time to time) light heal. I had a druid oog me once because he was bored and I was shocked by how much more efficient it was.


So, we DO, do well in group trainings but the problem is there are many stupid/blind people out there that do not care about efficiency and would rather just spend more money for the "quickest" kills and end up ONLY wanting a warrior/rogue team. Leaving the rangers out of the fun. No wonder I did not level my ranger that high, I had no leveling incentive. People like rogues would say leveling is booorinnggg but when I level I suddenly feel "happy" because I have not been able to for so damn long.

Alright, to counter:

1: Rangers are made to be able to kill 3-4*s easy, rouges are not... have you ever seen a rouge train alone on 4*s? In Crom, that rarely happens. Mostly because that 1.5k damage that you say these mobs do, would nearly kill a rouge in one hit, plus its autos. Even if a rouge is spamming restores, it cant keep up unless it has its own druid... or a ranger in group.

2: Camo, bolas and light heal. While it takes time to cast these skills, its time better spent casting, than wasting time dying, or fighting multiple mobs at once.
Also, your sarcastic remark about light heal and evasions... No. Light heal is only interrupted by skills, not autos. So a light heal timed correctly is never interrupted, and its much better than spending 200 gold every time you need 1000 health (which is multiple times a mob depending on *s).

3: Druids and rangers training together isn't much more efficient than solo with a ranger... Unless of course that druid had a good deal of damage skills, then of course you'd be killing faster than normal, but the exp would remain about the same.

What level is your ranger/rouge Chelseam2?

Re: Ranger Vs Rogue!

#58
Light heal is only interrupted by skills, not autos. So a light heal timed correctly is never interrupted
I never knew this...Is this true?

Also, maybe the ranger is good at some things, but they do seriously need a major buff in regards to skills and PvP.
Clan: WolfGang
Chaz - Level 185+ Ranger - Full DL
Inferno19 - Level 127+ Mage
Sneakystrike - Level 195+ Rogue - Full DL
EpIcHeaLzz - Level 137+ Druid
Tankerzz - Level 127+ Warrior (PvP Beast: Invincible Veteran)

World: Mabon

Re: Ranger Vs Rogue!

#59
I never knew this...Is this true?

Also, maybe the ranger is good at some things, but they do seriously need a major buff in regards to skills and PvP.
I haven't used light heal in a few months, but Im pretty sure that can't be interupted by autos, and of it is, it rarely ever is truly interupted.

... And I can agree with you about pvp, I just stay out of arena and don't duel: it's a pointless feature anyways.

Re: Ranger Vs Rogue!

#60
The thing is, the average ranger is nothing compared to other classes in terms of power, yes bolas is the only decent support skill we have but that one skill should not define us.

Light heal has to be in range to be used... For an end game ranger whos mainly str, it does about 800. Dps over an 800 heal is valued more.

Rangers should have 2 paths to choose from, a support or dps. Druids can be an awesome healer and an even better dps due to their skills. Warriors have tank skills and dps skills as well.
What do we have? This is where I am saying you are delusional. All the raid gear you can get will not undermine the fact that we are a broken class and are forgotten, only thing that is keeping us alive is bolas, i am saying this as a ranger who has played for 3 years and i would say we are the worst class at the moment.
Wattzon of Sulis

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 24 guests