Celtic Heroes

For that extra challenge, maybe more players in these top clans could choose a build that requires alot of running around and paying attention in order to survive. Pigman might have the right idea there.
Think of the fun you'll have!

I did and you are mistaken. It is a mmo

1.5k hp
You just have to play smart to not die. No, i cant just sit and auto like other rogues do it forces me to pay attention and move around. When im lazy i die a lot when i actually pay attention to the raid i hardly die

There shouldnt be the lazy option when killing a boss, everyon should be engaged in the fight

This is interesting. You have chosen a build that requires you to disengange from the boss and run around in order to stay alive.
What impact does this have on your overall dps on the boss, do you think?

Did you choose this build for effectiveness or just for the pure challenge of it?

I get mord kills with this build, and the last hru kill i was at
So its both

My point is that it is completely possible and viable

I would still like to get some insight on the questions in the original post.

• 1. Are the loudest arguments for the idol nerf coming from members of the top clans of servers?
  
  2. Is there agreement that introducing the idol nerf now on iOS servers will make it more difficult for an aspiring clan to eventually catch up to the top clan on their server?

You can answer #1 by surveying posts on this topic and list the world and clan of those in favor vs. those against. Granted, this info isn't available in all sig files but there should be enough to get an idea.

#2. I think it is pretty clear the idol nerf will widen the gap between the haves and have nots in the game.

1.5k hp
You just have to play smart to not die. No, i cant just sit and auto like other rogues do it forces me to pay attention and move around. When im lazy i die a lot when i actually pay attention to the raid i hardly die

There shouldnt be the lazy option when killing a boss, everyon should be engaged in the fight

This is interesting. You have chosen a build that requires you to disengange from the boss and run around in order to stay alive.
What impact does this have on your overall dps on the boss, do you think?

Did you choose this build for effectiveness or just for the pure challenge of it?

I get mord kills with this build, and the last hru kill i was at
So its both

My point is that it is completely possible and viable

Not without Plat items it's not.

A lot of people promoting this idea assume that everyone runs around lixed up with several druids behind them, using platinum items at will. Unfortunately not everyone has this luxury and will not successfuly kill bosses without using several restos and lixes if this happens.

Having a neutral mindset will help this game so please for the sake of bettering this game think neutrally. Im in a dominant clan in Gwydion and if this nerf happens, the opposing clans in our world wont be able to take down many bosses with this. All this nerf is doing is going to screw up non dominant clan.

So, from a selfish point of view

Exactly, lots of ppl here talk from how it is for them. Im in the top clan and im a warrior, obviously i can survive longer than all other classes if i want, but i'll have to sacrifice the skills i want to use or needed for my dps for something that will drastically decrease my enjoyment (im talking about being forced to change skills), even without this skills there needs to be some sort of reasonable amount of survivability and self regen skills/gear.
Also, OTM hve made lots of things to avoid death penalty, or to make this game less challengeable, such as popping heroic travel/going on my mount and run all Sreng's adds without even getting hit, challenge? Nah, easy as hell.
Running the way to boss, need group and fight them? Not really, if i want extra survivability i equip my shield and pop heroic travel and dont idol even once on the way to Snorri, i can use inv pot or heroic regen as well (plus they just added heroic armour and defence too).

There are lots of ways to avoid death penalty, most of them are plat based, but the only way needed to avoid death penalty is improving game mechanics making death more critical but far more rare.

Well said ^

If you think that pirates and scorpians are OP, you must be doing something wrong.

I was saying for characters without the lux boosts it would be a pain in the ass because of how hard it is to stay alive.

Well said ^

+1