Celtic Heroes

Capital punishment or the death penalty is a legal process whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime.

This is a definition. The situation isn't the same as sniper's etc.
I don't say that army has to be disbanded. Sometimes, sadly, violence and death are "needed". But death penalty isn't needed, the criminal won't be able to commit crimes in jail, so why would he kill him ? And how would it help ?

Some people aren't fit to exist. I would rather a man who rapes animals and strangles children be erased then to have him "fixed". There should be no amnesty.

Capital punishment or the death penalty is a legal process whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime.

This is a definition. The situation isn't the same as sniper's etc.
I don't say that army has to be disbanded. Sometimes, sadly, violence and death are "needed". But death penalty isn't needed, the criminal won't be able to commit crimes in jail, so why would he kill him ? And how would it help ?

Some people aren't fit to exist. I would rather a man who rapes animals and strangles children be erased then to have him "fixed". There should be no amnesty.

I disagree, resources should be used to figure out why said man does what he does, treat his blatant mental illness, and use that knowledge to treat people in the future.

I'm against it, if your leg breaks you fix it, not cut it off.

I'm against it, if your leg breaks you fix it, not cut it off.

For the record, I'm not officially in this discussion yet... But! If your legs cause harm to the rest of your body or has an unavoidable potential to, you slice it off; you are better off without it.

(Hope I got your metaphor right)

I'm against it, if your leg breaks you fix it, not cut it off.

For the record, I'm not officially in this discussion yet... But! If your legs cause harm to the rest of your body or has an unavoidable potential to, you slice it off; you are better off without it.

(Hope I got your metaphor right)

I believe you should study the leg, take care of it and learn about its illness so you can prevent it in other peopke

I also believe ppl can be fixed, but the jails need to be adjusted for that.

Killing is still not a solution :/

I'm against it, if your leg breaks you fix it, not cut it off.

For the record, I'm not officially in this discussion yet... But! If your legs cause harm to the rest of your body or has an unavoidable potential to, you slice it off; you are better off without it.

(Hope I got your metaphor right)

I believe you should study the leg, take care of it and learn about its illness so you can prevent it in other peopke

There isn't just one infected leg here..there are thousands..and thousands undiscovered. We are trusting a couple of bandages to contain them. Bandages are not at all the ideal way to isolate such dangerous amounts of infected legs. Sure...amputation is the easy way out; no argument there. So why struggle instead for the time- and resource-consuming way?

Amputation is the best way.



I do agree on one thing though. Our diagnosis process is not at all perfect; there is too much room for mistakes. Therefore, maybe..just maybe...the world may need to hold off on amputations...

Other than that...these arguments that infected legs can be cured or treated with bandages are utter Bullcrap! Some legs are just too infected and they prefer the infection over the cure. All they deserve is amputation.

Also...thinking of executions as killings is kind of curving the truth...just saying...

There is also the point that if they are found to be innocent you can't unlock a jail cell and apy them off for your mistakes.

Here's another metaphor:

I've been asked why we lock topics instead of deleting them, the simple answer is that if another mod or admins sees it from a different perspective and doesn't see any rules being broken, it is simply unlocked, whereas if a topic is deleted there is no "undo" button.

There is also the point that if they are found to be innocent you can't unlock a jail cell and apy them off for your mistakes

Covered that.

I do agree on one thing though. Our diagnosis process is not at all perfect; there is too much room for mistakes. Therefore, maybe..just maybe...the world may need to hold off on amputations...

I agree buddy. With the current justice system, there is too much room for error. Maybe you and others will disagree with my other opinion: errors in prosecution aside, coldblooded murderers deserve to be executed (not killed! Executed!)