Celtic Heroes

Wait wait, I guess we'd need to find out what to do about exp and gold maybe that could stay to whoever did most damage?

Im merging this with an existing KS topic.

Rofl why I don't understand this topic at all.

And this is a pure example of why combining post by mods is abusive I have never read this thread at all and he chooses to wipe out my created topic to put it 3rd page on this topic.

Last time I looked there's over 100 kS topics idiot, so why do you merge mine?
How about you leave my post up and copy this to here if you think this topic is so great
And I'll add the only reason why you added it to this one is because it's the one that's being talked about today.
Xell how on earth did you get mod?

But then if you want agro but taunt warcry and shield bash take away you will never get kill even though u want agro this idea has not been thought through at all I mean as a rogue I go up start get hit few times but I have Druid an bam warrior comes keeps agro with maxed warcry taunt and shield bash I do most damage but ur saying he should get kill??! No I don't think I because I could want that agro but I would never beable to pull it off him this would make warriors miles over powered and there is only room for problems in this idea keep it simple it's not hard who ever has most agro at end gets 20% more points for group is more then enough give Druids buff which in increase att and bam a group with 3 dps 1 tank 1 Mage 3 Druids could easily get kill over 6 rogues maybe 7/8 even!

But then if you want agro but taunt warcry and shield bash take away you will never get kill even though u want agro this idea has not been thought through at all I mean as a rogue I go up start get hit few times but I have Druid an bam warrior comes keeps agro with maxed warcry taunt and shield bash I do most damage but ur saying he should get kill??! No I don't think I because I could want that agro but I would never beable to pull it off him this would make warriors miles over powered and there is only room for problems in this idea keep it simple it's not hard who ever has most agro at end gets 20% more points for group is more then enough give Druids buff which in increase att and bam a group with 3 dps 1 tank 1 Mage 3 Druids could easily get kill over 6 rogues maybe 7/8 even!

Are you fighting a mob you can kill by yourself? If you are doing the damage, but not getting attacked, there is no risk for you. It is easy to imagine that dps is the only measure, since we can see the boss die as a result. It is not the only measure or their would be no classes other than rogues.

We are suggesting an aggro/dps balanced calculation. It is important to understand that this balanced between the two and not one or the other. It is not just aggro. It is not just dps. If you agree their should be measures other than dps, how do you feel those might be included, if not this way? If you think dps is the only measure then you are saying that it should stay the way it is. The way it is devalues the efforts of all non-dps classes.

Wait wait, I guess we'd need to find out what to do about exp and gold maybe that could stay to whoever did most damage?

I feel that awarding drops/gold on a percentage basis would be a horrible can of worms and break apart all the advantages of grouping. I feel that the kill should be awarded completely to one group and the drops allocated according to the present coding.

Hey guys, check out my ideas on this topic, I've posted them in a few places and don't feel like retyping, the most recent one is my responce on Xells thread in Feedback and Suggestions about how updates are coming along (title: Feedback and Suggestions FAQ). I think they are very good ideas and would solve these problems.

Check them out and let me know what you think on this thread or where I posted them.
Thanks.

I am adding solutions to the main text of the post as people post their solution.

What if instead of a target lock there was a first hit contribution of 25%. So the first hit gives the equivalent of the credit of 25% of the kill's hp?

The OP is very useful now. Thank you.