Celtic Heroes

Holy COW this thread lol.... Both drops should go to tank and should be re rolled for by the two rogues...One rogue can not get 2 drops when there are 2 or more rogues present...Dr. Pepper I am totally gonna have to disagree with you on this one haha....Roll for the two drops so both have a chance at both instead of automatically being stuck with the worse drop...That my opinion of course if you disagree that's fine, everyone likes different ways

interesting
Anyway let's get it sorted out.. But not too fast, love debates.

And doctor pepper my sister is 5 so probably not her... Haha

The problem is if there are 3 rogues and 2 drops then you obviously just keep the one drop if you won it in group without a roll and the other two roll for the 2nd drop

But the 'lucky' rogue that instantly got drop in group has no chance for ench. They may complain a bit :p

Holy COW this thread lol.... Both drops should go to tank and should be re rolled for by the two rogues...One rogue can not get 2 drops when there are 2 or more rogues present...Dr. Pepper I am totally gonna have to disagree with you on this one haha....Roll for the two drops so both have a chance at both instead of automatically being stuck with the worse drop...That my opinion of course if you disagree that's fine, everyone likes different ways

That option was always out there, but Fighter's idea was more than unfair. Rerolling with the tank is the best idea, but at the same time, the game did roll already. Didn't it? So being stuck with the sucky drop could happen if the tank rerolled both drops could still give the rogue a bad drop. If we did that, then the rogue (say he actually got dropped with the good drop) had to reroll it and then he complained that he had it, but then lost when it rerolled. Each scenario is the same chances.

Ok we have three options then.

Doctor peppers option - the rogue it dropped to keeps whatever they get and the other drop goes to the other rogue(s)

Fighters option - the rogue who got drop keeps it and ALL rogues including them can roll for the second

Crushers option - Just give the tank all drops and reroll for them.


Vote!

Ok we have three options then.

Doctor peppers option - the rogue it dropped to keeps whatever they get and the other drop goes to the other rogue(s)

Fighters option - the rogue who got drop keeps it and ALL rogues including them can roll for the second

Crushers option - Just give the tank all drops and reroll for them.


Vote!

From an outsider's perspective - Both rogues roll and the winner gets to pick what they want. the loser gets the other.

You can also use the same method for 3 purple drops and 4 rogues etc, Top 3 rolls get to pick in order what they want, and one rogue doesn't get any.

Simple, easy to implement and fair, no?

Ok we have three options then.

Doctor peppers option - the rogue it dropped to keeps whatever they get and the other drop goes to the other rogue(s)

Fighters option - the rogue who got drop keeps it and ALL rogues including them can roll for the second

Crushers option - Just give the tank all drops and reroll for them.


Vote!

From an outsider's perspective - Both rogues roll and the winner gets to pick what they want. the loser gets the other.

You can also use the same method for 3 purple drops and 4 rogues etc, Top 3 rolls get to pick in order what they want, and one rogue doesn't get any.

Simple, easy to implement and fair, no?

Nahhh go back to morrigon. jk so basically you vote for crusher's option

Ok we have three options then.

Doctor peppers option - the rogue it dropped to keeps whatever they get and the other drop goes to the other rogue(s)

Fighters option - the rogue who got drop keeps it and ALL rogues including them can roll for the second

Crushers option - Just give the tank all drops and reroll for them.


Vote!

Crushers option is the best hands down to be honest, and why even vote? 5 people don't make server rules anyways we do what we have always done, drops to tank and reroll.

Yes I already said in the first post that handing to tank was easiest solution, but since we have 'drop to right class - keep' rule too it would be fun to talk about it. Just read the first page and you will see there's lots of ways to go about this. I also said that the couple times I have seen it happen there was confusion.. And still is so why say it's what we have always done?

And I also didn't say "just 5 people can vote and decide" I said "vote" on a public post so everyone can do it. Don't know why you are saying there is a few that make all the rules, everyone is always given chance to talk and share thier opinion.