Celtic Heroes

No it's not, Mighty Crown Shield of Spirits is. I know it cuz i've had both

Mighty Crown Shield of Spirits
Armour:60
Weight:20
Mp regen:10
Hp regen:10
Hp:100
Mp:100

Mighty Shield of Crowns
Armour:60
Weight:20
Mp regen:0
Hp regen:15
Hp:100

Extra!

Connatch Vanquisher Shield(obviously worse than both above, but rarer and more valuable)
Armour:45
Weight:40
Mp regen:0
Hp regen:0
Attk: 35

Thanks!!

Mighty Crown Shield of Spirits is still better. It only has 5 less health regen, and healer(s) behind can just cast embrace, which is MUCH stronger than 5 per tick. The Mighty Crown Shield of Spirits also has 10 energy regen, in which the Mighty Shield of Crowns doesn't. 10 mp per tick is a LOT to warriors, and when the warrior constantly have more energy, he/she can cast Protective Stance(, which is obviously good for a tank), Giant Swing, and Pummel. It ALSO has 100 total energy. There, did i just prove my point?

Sorry to go off topic but your title makes the most sense for this question.

Do offhand weapons add damage to the main hand attack or is it a separate attack? I have heard both and if so which ones do what? I cant tell from the stats.

i have the golden blade of battle and i notice it has a seperate attack from my falcion. hope that helps.

Mighty Crown Shield of Spirits is still better. It only has 5 less health regen, and healer(s) behind can just cast embrace, which is MUCH stronger than 5 per tick. The Mighty Crown Shield of Spirits also has 10 energy regen, in which the Mighty Shield of Crowns doesn't. 10 mp per tick is a LOT to warriors, and when the warrior constantly have more energy, he/she can cast Protective Stance(, which is obviously good for a tank), Giant Swing, and Pummel. It ALSO has 100 total energy. There, did i just prove my point?

No i dont think you proved your point.... Most successful tanks earn money fast and have a golden/heroic rejuv i only use golden and cast all the skills u listed above and never run out!? So what exactly is the point of getting more energy regeneration??? The extra 60k is definately not worth it.

Actually, with the new slower energy resto during combat, I'm thinking of trading in my Mighty Shield of Spirits for a Might Shield of Crowns.

As a note, I did buy a diamond bludgeon for my off hand -- and find that I'm less effective with that than I am my sword/shield, even though I have protective stance maxed.
If you want to do a tank/dps combo, I'd suggest getting a one handed weapon and shield and a two handed weapon as an alternate.

Mighty Crown Shield of Spirits is still better. It only has 5 less health regen, and healer(s) behind can just cast embrace, which is MUCH stronger than 5 per tick. The Mighty Crown Shield of Spirits also has 10 energy regen, in which the Mighty Shield of Crowns doesn't. 10 mp per tick is a LOT to warriors, and when the warrior constantly have more energy, he/she can cast Protective Stance(, which is obviously good for a tank), Giant Swing, and Pummel. It ALSO has 100 total energy. There, did i just prove my point?

Primo, look your "only" 5 health regen: 5x60 : 300 and so on. It's cool for long fights.
Secundo, Mighty Crown Shield has 150 health. Spirits 100.
Tertio, we don't care Giant Swing or pummel, I told you it's a tank, we only want Warcry, Taunt or Stance, sorry.

PS: Now with the update, the better shield for a tank is Diamond. Or Mighty Shield of Crowns, still, cause of his 150 health and regens.

best shield for normal warrior plying (solo,pvp,tanking) is the mighty crown shields of spirits.
New energy costs are giant.
Even for a tank i would prefer it, because u really need the energy regen (heroic wont be enough).
Without it its alomst impossible to use Taunt,Stance and Shield bash on cooldown.
Shield bash will be much more worth then 5 Health regen.
Shield bash stuns a mob for 5 seconds (every 30 seconds), thats ca. 2 attack that you can prevent every 30 seconds (so on bosses around 300 damage). The mighty crown shield will only regen 5*6=30 health in the cooldown time of shieldbash.

In my humble opinion you have two off-hand options for warriors with the new skills and energy demands....

1] TANK - Mighty Shield of Crowns: same as before but don't skill attack, skill defense only, otherwise energy loss is too great.
2] DPS - Off hand golden bodkin of spirits, means you can skill attack all the time with no loss of energy and it still regens health, albeit not as much as shield, but it does speed up the kills.

Like i say in my opinion and it works for me. The diamond off-hands are good (hit harder and faster) but they don't regen anything, which makes them less favorable in my eyes... and the torso, legs and helm help alot.. Loving the update, just can't play enough to level dam it....lol